My Keurig is my most used appliance in my house – sometimes I feel like the 4th or 5th cup isn’t doing anything for me at all. That’s why I was recently interested in trying out mushroom coffee – could this be the answer to my waning afternoon energy?
Unfortunately, many popular brands don’t offer a “pod” or “k-cup” version of their coffee, so it was hard for me to give it a try.
Over the last few months, I’ve purchased a few of the most popular mushroom coffee pods and wanted to share some of my experiences.
Four Sigmatic has actually been around since 2012, where they originally started selling instant mushroom coffee on Amazon. People thought they were crazy – after all – who wants to DRINK mushrooms?
Since then, they’ve become one of the most popular coffee sellers on Amazon, receiving thousands upon thousands of glowing 5-star reviews. I had to try for myself.
Pros
- Organic Ingredients. One of the things that stood out to me was the organic packaging and ingredients. Four Sigmatic really carries their brands as being someone that cares about health, nature, and the environment. I appreciated that they sourced their ingredients organically.
- Taste. For being a coffee with mushrooms – It wasn’t awful tasting. As opposed to a product like RYZE, the mushroom coffee includes primarily coffee grounds with mushroom extract – Chaga, Lion’s Mane and Rhodiola. I found that even black – it wasn’t far off from your average cup of coffee and with a little bit of oat milk, it was divine.
- Energy Effectiveness. I felt a more subtle and calmer energy, while it still got me out of my morning slump. I might’ve just been falling for the placebo effect, but I didn’t really feel the need for more than one cup.
- Variety. If you’re planning to buy the pods, you can choose from a few variations – “Think”, or “Think” high caffeine each with their own combination of mushrooms and herbs.
Cons
- The only critique here is that I wish they offered larger quantities instead of just the 10 count. At that count, the price per ounce is pretty steep.
Pricing
Like many coffee products on Amazon, you’re given the “subscribe and save” option with Four Sigmatic 12-count. Without it, it’ll cost you $15.36
If you’ve spent any time scrolling wellness blogs or TikTok lately, you’ve probably seen mushroom coffee popping up everywhere. As someone always looking for healthier swaps (especially for my beloved morning coffee), I had to try Cuppa Mushroom Coffee to see what the fuss was all about.
First Impressions
The packaging is sleek and minimal, which I love—definitely something you’d be proud to keep on your counter. It’s marketed as a blend of organic coffee with lion’s mane, chaga, and cordyceps mushrooms, aiming to boost focus, immunity, and energy without the jitters.
The coffee itself? Surprisingly smooth. I was honestly skeptical about the taste (let’s be real, mushrooms and coffee don’t sound like a dream combo), but Cuppa nailed it. There’s no weird earthy aftertaste—just a rich, medium roast flavor. I did notice it’s a little less bitter than my usual brew, which made it easy to drink black or with a splash of oat milk.
Effects
The real test: how did I feel after drinking it? I swapped out my normal coffee for a full week. I definitely felt more “even” energy—no crazy spike and crash like with regular coffee. I also noticed I stayed focused longer into the afternoon, especially on work-heavy days. It didn’t give me superhuman powers (no magic mushrooms here!), but it did feel like a subtle, steadier boost.
Ingredients & Sourcing
I appreciate that Cuppa is transparent about their ingredients. The mushrooms are organic and dual-extracted (meaning you get both the water- and fat-soluble compounds), and the coffee is sustainably sourced. Big wins for me in terms of quality.
Finally, pods that come with a greater count than 15. Beyond that, the Bulletproof coffee brand is reliable, and I had actually tried some of their grounds before.
Pros
- A lot of caffeine. There is much more caffeine than your regular cup of coffee – 175 mg to be exact. It goes a long way, especially with the added B vitamins and Lion’s mane extract.
- Taste. You can’t taste the mushrooms at all, which unsurprisingly is a big plus in my book. It just seemed like your average, if not better than average coffee.
- Cleaner ingredients. BulletProof says that they “test” the ingredients for toxins, but I don’t know what type of bean they use. It looks like they are sourced from Guatemala, so at least that’s a step up from some other mushroom coffee brands.
Cons
- Pricey. These k-cups will cost around $1.50 a pod, which is a better value than Starbucks but still a little expensive.
Pricing
- The 10 pack is $14.99 and the 24 pack runs $34.99
SOLLO’s Dark roast was surprisingly pleasant. These gluten-free, organic, and 100% Arabica coffee pods are worth a try.
Pros
- 100% Arabica. This was the only mushroom coffee I found that specifically stated it was 100% Arabica beans – which typically means higher quality.
- Weight Loss Reviews. If one of your goals is weight loss, several reviews stated that they had lost weight while drinking.
- Less hunger. I noticed I had high energy with a curbed appetite.
Cons
- Flavor. The coffee didn’t taste bad, but it didn’t taste as good as some of the others.
Price
- A 24 pack will set you back $34.95 on Amazon
Conclusion
In the pursuit of an energy-boosting and health-conscious coffee fix, mushroom coffee pods have emerged as an intriguing option. As a regular Keurig user, I sought a remedy for my diminishing afternoon caffeine kick. The concept of mushroom-infused coffee held promise, and after trying several brands, I’m excited to share my findings.
Four Sigmatic’s Think Organic Coffee stood out with its organic ingredients and surprisingly palatable taste. Its gentle, sustained energy lift was a welcome change, though the limited pod quantity was a downside.
Bulletproof’s The High Achiever Pods packed a caffeine punch with B vitamins and Lion’s Mane extract, all while delivering a taste that masked the mushroom presence. Though pricier, it’s a solid investment for a potent morning jolt.
SOLLO’s Dark Roast Chaga Mushroom Coffee Pods focused on 100% Arabica beans and hinted at potential weight loss effects. While the flavor might not have been top-notch, its health benefits intrigued those seeking more from their cup.
In the end, the world of mushroom coffee pods is diverse, offering options for various tastes and wellness goals. Whether you’re drawn to organic allure, bold flavors, boosted caffeine, or potential health perks, there’s a mushroom coffee for you.